What are the differences between the baseball movie the natural. In the movie the natural, why does harriet bird shoot. But in barry levinsons the natural roy hobbs ends with fireworks and fanfare. And as the book concludes, cries many bitter tears. Roy hobbs, in the novel, is a weak man who just cannot seem to learn from his mistakes. Roys character is more flawed in the book than in the movie, and the ending of the story is very different. Roy hobbs, fictional character, the ambitious and talented but flawed baseball player who is the protagonist of the natural 1952, the first novel by american writer bernard malamud. The book is basically about the characters flaws that lead him to his fate.
According to legend, billy would draw a circle on the side of a barn and tell young roy to hit that. Even if the answer to your question were in the book. This tournament brings people of all ages from all over the world together to enjoy the game of baseball. There goes roy hobbs, the best there ever was in the game. The natural stands the test of time more than 30 years. The transformation from book into film is epitomized by the turn from unhappy to. The natural 3 essay the natural, a story bases on a man by the name of roy hobbs.
Some people like to think that robert redford s character, roy hobbs, in the movie, the natural, was supposed to be inspired by boston red sox outfielder ted williams. The roy hobbs family works yearround to make the roy hobbs world series one of the best amateur baseball events around. Roy hobbs officials will investigate at their discretion. As has been mentioned about a half dozen times or so in this thread hobbs is an amalgamation of many ballplayers, babe ruth included. In bernard malamuds the natural, roy hobbs ends in. The genuine article, the crack of the bat, the feel of game ready leather. Roys drive to be the best in the book comes off as fanatical, as opposed to an envious athlete trait of insatiable drive that is usually revered and admired in the movie. Roy hobbs, the natural literature rarely lends itself to the feelgood endings of traditional hollywood fare. And then when i walked down the street people wouldve looked and they wouldve said there goes roy hobbs, the best there ever was in this game. The story follows roy hobbs, a baseball prodigy whose career is sidetracked. His tragic downfall demise roy is the perfectly talented athlete who, despite his good intentions, fails to live up to the worlds expectations of him.
The novel and the film are not siblings or even distant cousins. Encouraged by his father alan fudge, hobbs is told by him that he has an amazing gift for throwing a baseball, but he needs more than that if he is to succeed and play in the big leagues. If you watch the movie when roy has lunch with gus he makes a bet with roy that he can guess how much money he has in his wallet. Hobbs was shot en route to a baseball tryout as a teenager and never made it to the majors until he was 34 years old.
He joined the new york knights and, after the death of the starter, bump baily, took over in the outfield left in the. The natural 18 movie clip striking out the whammer. For all of his physical tools, roy cannot overcome his personal flaws. In the movie roy finds out iris is pregnant during the last game. However, after being shot by the sultry, murderous harriet bird, leaving him with a permanent limp, hobbs baseball career is limited to the semipro leagues until he is hired to play for. Based on the 1952 bernard malamud novel of the same name, the natural follows redford as hobbs, a promising baseball phenom whose career is derailed after being shot by a serial killer while on his way to try out for the big leagues. Am i the last person to notice that roy hobbs struck out. Like the book, the film recounts the experiences of roy hobbs, an individual. William hobbs, the innovative fight director, fencing master and stuntman who choreographed action sequences for such films as the three musketeers, the duellists and rob roy, has died.
It seems theres a fascinating story there, in itself. In the movie, the femme fatale was played by actress barbara hershey and her character commits suicide after shooting redfords character, roy hobbs. After his date with memo, roy goes into a slump and cant get any hits. From the movie the natural starring robert redford and music by randy newman. His father, william, had played some semiprofessional baseball before settling on a farm. Check out our video to see and hear what it is like to be a part of the rhws. Featured items newest items bestselling alphabetical. Roy hobbs, pop fisher, sam simpson, wonderboy, red blow, max mercy, memo paris, bump baily, iris lemon, judge goodwill banner, gus sands, harriet bird, otto p. Roy, surprisingly, did not have many flaws to begin with. The first difference i noticed was that there was an absence or a change in many scenes. After roy tells her he will be the greatest in the game, she shoots him. Baseball is the american game and hobbs the homegrown hero, complete with legendary accoutrements.
Some people like to think that robert redfords character, roy hobbs, in the movie, the natural, was supposed to be inspired by boston red sox outfielder ted williams. Id love to get to know pop fisher wilford brimley, the cynical, old team manager. The team celebrates roy hobbs day, and he gets a new car. The character was portrayed by robert redford in the 1984 film version of the. Roys drive to be the best in the book comes off as fanatical, as opposed to an envious athlete trait of insatiable drive that is usually revered and admired in the real world and the movie. Of all its characters, the only one we dont want to know more about is roy hobbs. With robert redford, robert duvall, glenn close, kim basinger.
A film adaptation of the natural, starring robert redford as roy hobbs, was released in 1984. The natural retains author bernard malamuds classical allusions to homer and the king arthur legend, shaping the biggerthanlife tale of roy hobbs into a quest betrayed. Hobbs wish was to become one of the most popular baseball players ever existed in history. Roy hobbs was born in sabotac valley, iowa in 1904, the same year as hall of famer chuck klein.
As it turns out, the book and the film, more than anything, are really a tale of two different roy hobbs. He played both the 19 year old and 35 year old roy. He is by no means a mentor, or someone that children can easily turn to. For example, there is no car scene with memo and roy in the movie, roy is a right fielder instead of a left fielder in the movie, and also, iris, roys girlfriend, is not a. Eastern time on the thursday of the week in which the team is competing, and state the basis for such challenge. I coulda broke every record in the book recent views. The natural is roy hobbs, an american parsifal, a baseball player granted. After the game, the bribe situation is revealed to the public, by the always lurking sports writer, and roy hobbs is left broken and disgraced. In his first film appearance in four years, robert redford plays roy hobbs, a farm boy with a hankering to be a great baseball player. Roy hobbs uncut sheets from the natural used in movie. The score has often been compared to the style of aaron copland and.
Malamuds hobbs can be viewed as a tragic hero a character who possesses a flaw that. William hobbs, fight director on swashbuckling classics. The film was nominated for four academy awards, including best supporting actress close, and it was nominated for a golden globe award for best supporting actress kim basinger. This story reminds me of a book i once read a little while ago. The difference in the presence of kids in the book and movie make or break roy hobbs as the perfect hero, and the heros journey that he is on. The pittsburgh manager then decides to change pitchers with the count at 11. With his faithful homemade bat wonderboy in hand, roy heads. In roy hobbs last at bat of the movie he takes the 1st pitch for a called strike. An unknown comes seemingly out of nowhere to become a legendary baseball player with almost divine talent.
Roy hobbs is a fictional baseball player from the 1952 bernard malamud novel the natural, made into the 1984 movie in which hobbs was played by robert redford. Remember the scene w they showed hobbs cards being printed on the press to meet the demand of his adoring fans. The book ending really changes the whole tone of the story when i reflect back on it. Memo and roy go out for a drive in his new car, and roy thinks they might have run over a boy and his dog in the fog, but he cant find any traces of them. The natural is a 1952 novel by bernard malamud that was made into a film of the same name in 1984, starring robert redford as the books protagonist, roy hobbs though the film changed the novels conclusion, in both the book and the film hobbs is shot as a teen by a deranged woman while en route from his native northernus rocky mountain region to a tryout with the chicago cubs. Wow, after years of watching the natural between videotvdvd i finally decided to track down a copy of the book, and let me tell ya, what a downer. Many of the baseball scenes were filmed in 1983 at war memorial stadium in buffalo, new york, built in 1937 and demolished in 1988. Billy hobbs desperately wanted his son to become a major league player. This excerpt is one of my favorites from any sports movie.
The natural is a 1952 novel about baseball by bernard malamud, and is his debut novel. This page is for education about and discussion of the lonely killer depression and to remove the negative stigma associated with it. The natural is a 1984 american sports film based on bernard malamuds 1952 novel of the same name, directed by barry levinson and starring robert redford, glenn close, and robert duvall. This time, he embraces the beginning of the baseball season with a comparison of book and film versions of roy hobbs. What are the differences between the baseball movie the. The natural is baseball fantasy, a modern myth that borrows elements freely from arthurian and baseball legends.
Each of our products brings back the glory days of americas favorite pastime and manufactured to the highest standards of quality. He strikes out, throws the series, is left broke, unloved, an outcast. He resurfaces many years later and after a shaky start helps the fictitious new york knights get back on track and provides baseball movie fans with two fantastic. Roy hobbs is the character in the book, the natural, by bernard malmud, written in 1952, and turned into a hollywood production in 1984, thrusting the fictional baseball hero roy hobbs on the american public.
The book ending really changes the whole tone of the story when i. Most of the story concerns itself with his attempts to return to baseball later in life, when he plays for the. The story follows roy hobbs, a baseball prodigy whose career is sidetracked when he is shot by a woman whose motivation remains mysterious. And a top 5 reasons you cant blame the filmmakers for changing the ending of the natural.
Ever savvy to his audiences tastes, redford insisted that the ending of the movie version be different from that of the book so that his character, roy hobbs, could wind up a. Home baseball 2017 roy hobbs world series hof inductions. Hobbs was from nebraska, a young phenom pitcher who had a gift for baseball at an early age. Quite a change from the robert redford movie version of roy hobbs who becomes a legend. Hes from some unnamed rural town out west and hasnt been anywhere else except boise and portland. The book the natural talks mostly about the heroic acts of roy hobbs, his strength of not giving up his wish. I guess going into the book i really expected it to carry the same character and inspiration that the movie had, but roy hobbs in the book. Yes, i know its fiction, but presumably this was based on a book or story of some kind, so somebody must know. Someday, in my other baseballthemed blog, uncle mikes musings, i play to do a top 5 reasons you cant blame bernard malamud for having roy hobbs strike out.
The mythic themes work so well in the movie version of the natural. Well, are the last two uncut sheets that i know of from that scene. Thinking about the difference between the roy we meet in the opening sentences and the roy we close the book on can tell us. The movie opens with the story of a young boy, roy hobbs paul sullivan jr. Robert duvall, as the evil sportswriter, max mercy, has had his part cut so badly that we only know he. Supposedly, when bernard malamud, an established novelist, sold the rights to the film the book was written in the 1950s, he told screenwriter philip dusenberry that it didnt matter if he changed the plot malamud wasnt going to see the movie anyway. Robert redford reveals his inspiration for roy hobbs in. Iris is his guenevere in this story and then the rest of the characters are like those from the story. Differences between the natural book vs movie page 1. Regarding the movie the natural, does anyone know what happened to roy hobbs robert redford between the time he was shot and the time he comes back out of retirement to play baseball. The baseball diamond is the setting for the drama of bernard malamuds the natural avon. But the movie doesnt have any fancy special effects the life of roy hobbs. Malamuds protagonist in the book and film is roy hobbs, an honorable, talented pitcher and hitter who begins with a promising start of a baseball career.
388 689 77 1049 164 960 1169 152 219 1463 459 1154 1598 57 431 746 682 1557 224 51 1268 545 258 671 1244 1142 877 1363 653 797 1085 1381